William Rensberger

NMLS # 125761

574-287-1152

bill@1stmidwestmortgage.com

What Our Customers Say About Us

We care what our customers think of us and so should you. We are partners in your business and your success is ours.

Rating
4.7
23 reviews
Chanc Ravish
Everything about working with Brett was excellent. I will not work with any other mortgage company again, nor will I allow anyone i care about to use any other company. 1st Midwest was top notch, don't waste your time shopping around, this is the right an ...
Everything about working with Brett was excellent. I will not work with any other mortgage company again, nor will I allow anyone i care about to use any other company. 1st Midwest was top notch, don't waste your time shopping around, this is the right answer.
Read more Hide

Chanc Ravish

2 years ago

Google G Posted on Google
Danielle
I am not a person to take the time to write reviews. However, this one needed to be written. I would HIGHLY recommend Brett to anyone buying a home. I am a first time home buyer and had no clue what I was getting into. I did my research and narrowed it do ...
I am not a person to take the time to write reviews. However, this one needed to be written. I would HIGHLY recommend Brett to anyone buying a home. I am a first time home buyer and had no clue what I was getting into. I did my research and narrowed it down to 3 different mortgage companies. I had 0 issues with the other 2, but we decided to go with this one thanks to Brett showing the eagerness and the willingness to work with people who had no idea what they were doing :) . From day one, Brett was on the ball with our pre-approval and every step there after. I have never felt so confident in an area that I am not familiar with. He explained everything step by step and was a phone call or an email away at all times. It was so smooth that it seemed like we had done this a thousand times before. Thanks to him, we had the absolute best experience a FIRST time homebuyer could have ever hoped for.
Read more Hide

Danielle

2 years ago

Google G Posted on Google
Justin Reeder
Brett recently did a refi on my house, super easy & transparent process. Worked with Brett the whole way vs staff at most other places. Refi was done very quickly. No surprises, always felt informed and very responsive. Highly recommend Brett Newtown ...
Brett recently did a refi on my house, super easy & transparent process. Worked with Brett the whole way vs staff at most other places. Refi was done very quickly. No surprises, always felt informed and very responsive. Highly recommend Brett Newtown for your financing needs.
Read more Hide

Justin Reeder

4 years ago

Google G Posted on Google
Erin Oliver
Bill was great to work with! From our initial sit down through the closing, the process was seamless. I highly recommend Bill and 1st Midwest Mortgage to anyone in need of mortgage services!
Bill was great to work with! From our initial sit down through the closing, the process was seamless. I highly recommend Bill and 1st Midwest Mortgage to anyone in need of mortgage services!

Erin Oliver

5 years ago

Google G Posted on Google
Todd Nelson
Brett Newton made the whole process as painless as possible. His diligence and follow through were exemplary. I cannot recommend he and 1st Midwest enough to any potential home buyer. Thank you for your excellent customer service, but more importantly ...
Brett Newton made the whole process as painless as possible. His diligence and follow through were exemplary. I cannot recommend he and 1st Midwest enough to any potential home buyer. Thank you for your excellent customer service, but more importantly the great rate and low cash to close.
Read more Hide

Todd Nelson

5 years ago

Google G Posted on Google
Marissa Ryan
Bill was SO wonderful!!! He got our loan done so fast and so seamless.
Bill was SO wonderful!!! He got our loan done so fast and so seamless.

Marissa Ryan

5 years ago

Google G Posted on Google
Corey Horner
I cant say enough about Bill and his team. My wife and I have used him twice now with nothing but amazing results both time. Bill truly cares about you and what he can do for you. On our first house, he worked with me on my credit score to get us appro ...
I cant say enough about Bill and his team. My wife and I have used him twice now with nothing but amazing results both time. Bill truly cares about you and what he can do for you. On our first house, he worked with me on my credit score to get us approved. On our most recent he worked with us and showed us options on how to proceed and what to do to get the best rates. Paying the UW Fee saved us .2% which was about 18K over the life of our loan. With Bill being a broker, he is able to truly get you the best deal he can. He isn't stuck trying to force you to go with one deal as you would walking into a bank. He provides options to you, which, in my opinion have always been better than anyone else. My wife and I were set to build and we were working with a preferred lender of the builder. Once we decided against building, we contacted Bill and he rescued us from extra fees and a higher interest rate the "Preferred Builder" was gouging us with. If you are thinking about buying a home and need a mortgage, please give him a call! You wont regret talking to him. Thanks again Bill for all of your hard work and dedication to getting us the best deal you could. Thanks, Corey & Cassandra
Read more Hide

Corey Horner

5 years ago

Google G Posted on Google
Scott Jacko
Bill at 1st Midwest was great to work with and easily had the best mortgage options we could find.
Bill at 1st Midwest was great to work with and easily had the best mortgage options we could find.

Scott Jacko

6 years ago

Google G Posted on Google
Kayleigh Brown
1st Midwest Mortgage did an awesome job! Brett Newton assisted us and made everything smoother for purchasing our first home. Anytime we had questions, he was more than willing to explain and walk us through. No matter the time of day, Brett answered our ...
1st Midwest Mortgage did an awesome job! Brett Newton assisted us and made everything smoother for purchasing our first home. Anytime we had questions, he was more than willing to explain and walk us through. No matter the time of day, Brett answered our calls or got back to us in a timely manner. We couldn't have asked for a better group to assist us. Thanks!
Read more Hide

Kayleigh Brown

6 years ago

Google G Posted on Google
Doug Greco
Bill and his team were absolutely great to work with. They always kept me in the loop as to what was happening and when it was happening. As a first time buyer I obviously had a lot of questions during the process and Bill would always take the time to an ...
Bill and his team were absolutely great to work with. They always kept me in the loop as to what was happening and when it was happening. As a first time buyer I obviously had a lot of questions during the process and Bill would always take the time to answer them. When he wasn't available I knew I could count on getting a return email or call. Thanks again Bill and everybody else at First Midwest.
Read more Hide

Doug Greco

6 years ago

Google G Posted on Google
Kristen Jones
This company from start to finish had our loan completed and ready to close in less than 1 week! I would HIGHLY recommend to anyone!
This company from start to finish had our loan completed and ready to close in less than 1 week! I would HIGHLY recommend to anyone!

Kristen Jones

6 years ago

Google G Posted on Google
Ben n Rebecca Payne
Great to work with; everything was smooth and easy. All questions were answered quickly and clearly and we felt well taken care of. Would definitely strongly recommend using their services! A pleasure to work with.
Great to work with; everything was smooth and easy. All questions were answered quickly and clearly and we felt well taken care of. Would definitely strongly recommend using their services! A pleasure to work with.

Ben n Rebecca Payne

6 years ago

Google G Posted on Google
Benjamin Woolet
Quick and easy process. Knowledgable and experienced in the industry. Communication was fast and we always knew what was going on. Closed on time for a new home purchase. Highly recommended.
Quick and easy process. Knowledgable and experienced in the industry. Communication was fast and we always knew what was going on. Closed on time for a new home purchase. Highly recommended.

Benjamin Woolet

7 years ago

Google G Posted on Google
Amanda Swords
THE BEST PLACE TO WORK WITH IN NORTHERN INDIANA!!!!! Bill was 100% on top of things and had our FHA loan closed within 30 days!!! That is unheard of with FHA!!! This company is on top of it and Bill is amazing!!!!!
THE BEST PLACE TO WORK WITH IN NORTHERN INDIANA!!!!! Bill was 100% on top of things and had our FHA loan closed within 30 days!!! That is unheard of with FHA!!! This company is on top of it and Bill is amazing!!!!!

Amanda Swords

8 years ago

Google G Posted on Google